1951 Karl Malden - A Streetcar Named Desire as "Harold 'Mitch' Mitchell"

1952 Anthony Quinn - Viva Zapata! as Eufemio Zapata

1953 Frank Sinatra - From Here to Eternity as "Pvt. Angelo Maggio"

1954 Edmond O'Brien - The Barefoot Contessa as "Oscar Muldoon"

1955 Jack Lemmon- Mister Roberts as "Ens. Frank Thurlowe Pulver"

1956 Anthony Quinn - Lust for Life as Paul Gauguin

1957 Red Buttons - Sayonara as "Airman Joe Kelly"

1958 Burl Ives - The Big Country as "Rufus Hannassey"

1959 Hugh Griffith - Ben-Hur as "Sheik Ilderim"

1960 Peter Ustinov- Spartacus as Lentulus Batiatus