1951 Kim Hunter - A Streetcar Named Desire as "Stella Kowalski"

1952 Gloria Grahame - The Bad and the Beautiful as "Rosemary Bartlow"

1953 Donna Reed - From Here to Eternity as "Alma Burke"

1954 Eva Marie Saint - On the Waterfront as "Edie Doyle"

1955 Jo Van Fleet - East of Eden as "Kate"

1956 Dorothy Malone - Written on the Wind as "Marylee Hadley"

1957 Miyoshi Umeki - Sayonara as "Katsumi Kelly"

1958 Wendy Hiller - Separate Tables as "Pat Cooper"

1959 Shelley Winters - The Diary of Anne Frank as Petronella Van Daan

1960 Shirley Jones - Elmer Gantry as "Lula Baines"