1961 George Chakiris - West Side Story as "Bernardo"

1962 Ed Begley - Sweet Bird of Youth as "Tom 'Boss' Finley"

1963 Melvyn Douglas - Hud as "Homer Bannon"

1964 Peter Ustinov - Topkapi "Arthur Simon Simpson"

1965 Martin Balsam - A Thousand Clowns as "Arnold Burns"

1966 Walter Matthau - The Fortune Cookie as "Willie Gingrich"

1967 George Kennedy - Cool Hand Luke as "Dragline"

1968 Jack Albertson - The Subject Was Roses as "John Cleary"

1969 Gig Young - They Shoot Horses, Don't They? as "Rocky"

1970 John Mills - Ryan's Daughter as "Michael"