1991 Jack Palance - City Slickers as "Curly Washburn"

1992 Gene Hackman - Unforgiven as "Little Bill Daggett"

1993 Tommy Lee Jones - The Fugitive as "Marshall Samuel Gerard"

1994 Martin Landau - Ed Wood as Bela Lugosi

1995 Kevin Spacey - The Usual Suspects as "Roger 'Verbal' Kint"

1996 Cuba Gooding, Jr. - Jerry Maguire as "Rod Tidwell"

1997 Robin Williams - Good Will Hunting as "Sean Maguire"

1998 James Coburn - Affliction as "Glen Whitehouse"

1999 Michael Caine - The Cider House Rules as "Dr. Wilbur Larch"

2000 Benicio del Toro - Traffic as "Javier Rodriguez"